From Stars to Signals: How AI Will Use Social Proof to Recommend Products
ChatGPT and other AI tools are moving into shopping. Here’s how reviews, ratings, and social proof will shape which products large language models recommend.
If you’ve been watching the moves from OpenAI and other players in the AI space, you’ll have noticed something big: large language models like ChatGPT aren’t just for answering questions anymore. They’re moving into product discovery and shopping. The new ChatGPT merchants feature is an early sign of where this is headed: AI guiding what people buy.
That raises a new question for businesses: when AI starts recommending products, how will it decide who gets shown and who gets skipped?
The answer, increasingly, is social proof. Reviews, ratings, testimonials, and trust signals are going to be critical inputs in how AI makes product recommendations. Just like people rely on the wisdom of the crowd when choosing what to buy, AI will lean on the same signals to make its choices.
This post explores how that shift will happen, why it matters, and what businesses should be doing today to prepare.
The AI Shift: From Information to Transactions
For the last 20 years, most online discovery has run through search engines. Type in a keyword, see a list of links, click, and buy. Ads, SEO, and star ratings all shaped who got visibility.
But LLMs like ChatGPT are starting to replace that journey with something simpler: “What’s the best running shoe under £150?” → instant recommendations.
The difference is huge:
One answer, not ten. Instead of browsing multiple sites, users may just trust the AI.
Less ad clutter. If the AI is the filter, traditional ad slots shrink.
Trust first. For the AI to recommend something, it needs confidence the product is reliable.
That last piece is where reviews, ratings, and other forms of social proof become non-negotiable.
Why Social Proof Will Be Central
Humans are wired to trust peer voices over brand promises. Social proof — the evidence that other people like us approve of something — is one of the strongest psychological levers in decision-making.
AI doesn’t “trust” the way people do, but it mirrors our behavior by weighting inputs that signal reliability. Here’s why reviews and ratings will be central in the AI shopping era:
Structured data. Ratings are clean, numeric signals. Easy for algorithms to parse.
Contextual patterns. AI can detect not just the score, but the themes: shipping delays, great service, poor durability.
Volume matters. Ten reviews isn’t enough. Hundreds or thousands make the signal stronger.
Authenticity checks. With review fraud rampant, AIs will likely prioritize verified reviews or cross-platform consistency.
The risk? If your review footprint is thin, negative, or inconsistent, you’ll simply be filtered out.
Transparency, Fairness, and the Psychology of Trust
Reviews aren’t just numbers, they’re stories. And they work because they hit two key psychological triggers:
Transparency. Customers want to see the good and the bad. A 4.5 star average feels more trustworthy than a perfect 5.0.
Fairness. People don’t expect perfection. They expect to be treated fairly if something goes wrong.
AI systems will reflect this too. A business with nothing but 5-star reviews may be flagged as suspicious, while one with a mix of positive and negative reviews (and thoughtful responses) may rank higher.
In other words, handling bad reviews well won’t just help with human buyers, it could determine whether AI puts your product in the recommendation set at all.
Reputation Management in the AI Era
Reputation management used to mean keeping an eye on Google and Yelp, maybe hiring a PR firm if things blew up. In 2025, it’s something bigger: feeding trustworthy, authentic social proof into the systems that shape discovery.
If your reviews are patchy, hidden, or negative, AI will see that as a risk signal. If they’re consistent, transparent, and positive, AI will see them as trust anchors.
This changes the role of reputation management from reactive cleanup to proactive growth strategy. It’s not just about looking good to potential customers anymore — it’s about looking good to the algorithms that decide whether you’re even visible.
How Businesses Can Prepare
So, how do you get ready for a world where AI recommendations depend on social proof? Here are the steps to focus on now:
1. Encourage Authentic Reviews
Don’t just hope customers leave reviews. Ask at the right time — the “happy moment” when they’re most likely to respond positively. Use direct links, QR codes, or one-click prompts to make it simple.
2. Monitor and Respond
Reviews aren’t static. Respond to every one, positive or negative. Not only does this show human customers you care, but it also creates a data trail of accountability that AI can parse.
3. Stop Bad Reviews Before They Spread
Send quick surveys after purchases or support interactions. Catch unhappy customers before they vent publicly. Route their feedback privately so you can resolve it.
4. Analyze Themes
Look beyond the star rating. What patterns emerge? If complaints about shipping keep appearing, fix the logistics. If pricing confusion is common, rewrite the checkout flow. Reviews are maps to operational improvements.
5. Diversify Your Review Footprint
Don’t rely on one platform. Google, Trustpilot, Amazon, G2, TripAdvisor, niche forums — the more consistent your presence, the stronger your AI trust signal.
What This Means for Different Businesses
Agencies
Agencies will need to help clients clean up their review presence across platforms. It won’t be enough to manage one Google profile — AI will scan the whole footprint.
E-Commerce Brands
Amazon reviews already shape conversions. As AI integrates more shopping recommendations, products with higher star averages and more detailed feedback will dominate.
SaaS Companies
Sites like G2 and Capterra will be even more critical. Enterprise buyers may trust AI-curated summaries of software reviews as much as analyst reports.
Local Services
For restaurants, dentists, or gyms, Google Maps and Yelp reviews will directly influence whether AI recommends you as “the best nearby option.”
Across all of these, one pattern holds: reputation is revenue.
The Bigger Picture: From SEO to “Reputation Optimization”
Think about how SEO evolved. In the early days, it was about stuffing keywords. Then it became about backlinks. Today it’s about authority and experience.
The same thing will happen with AI-driven recommendations. Businesses will optimize for reputation signals:
Average rating thresholds (e.g., 4.0+ to even be considered)
Review volume benchmarks
Thematic sentiment (delivery, quality, service)
Responsiveness and resolution
This is the new layer of optimization. You won’t just ask, “Are we ranking on Google?” You’ll ask, “Do we have the review health to be recommended by AI?”
Final Word
AI is changing how people shop. When tools like ChatGPT start recommending products directly, the deciding factor won’t just be price or features — it will be trust. And trust, increasingly, is measured in stars, reviews, and social proof.
Businesses that treat reputation management as a growth strategy, not a crisis fix, will thrive in this new landscape. Because when AI is the gatekeeper, your reviews aren’t just influencing people anymore — they’re influencing the algorithms that decide whether people ever see you at all.
👉 Want to make sure your brand is ready for the AI era? Reputation management platforms like Troof help you turn scattered reviews and feedback into a clear, trustworthy signal - for both humans and machines.
This in-depth guide breaks down Net Promoter Score (NPS) in plain English - what it is, why companies use it, and where it falls short. You’ll learn the pros and cons of NPS, how to avoid treating it like a vanity metric, and smarter ways to combine it with CSAT, CES, and review analysis.
An in-depth look at how star ratings influence conversions, backed by data and psychology. Explains why small rating shifts lead to big sales impacts and how businesses can manage reviews to stay competitive.
We analyzed 27,000+ Manchester Airport reviews to reveal how trust is built, broken, and repaired. The findings show that queues and pricing spark anger, while simple wins in service create lasting loyalty.